The center of Upper Saranac Lake. 1912 Fish Creek Bay is a deep, narrow bay on the west shore of Upper Saranac Lake just south of Whitney Point, opposite Saginaw Bay. Fish Creek enters the lake here, flowing from Floodwood Pond, Little Square Pond and Square Pond.

On the north shore is Whitney Point, site of William A. Rockefeller II's Camp Wonundra.  The south shore was the site of camps built by Pennsylvania Governor George H. Earle, Jr., later the site of Donaldson's Campsite.