| Term of office | Name | Birth/death |
| 1851-1852 | Ellis Eames | 1809-1882 |
| 1853-1854 | Evan Molbourne Green | 1814-1882 |
| 1855-1860 | Benjamin Kimball Bullock | 1821-1901 |
| 1861 | Ebenezer Hanks | 1815-1884 |
| 1861-1862 | Andrew Hunter Scott Sr. | 1815-1874 |
| 1863 | Isaac Bullock | 1825-1891 |
| 1863 | Benjamin Kimball Bullock | 1821-1901 |
| 1864-1867 | William Miller | 1814-1875 |
| 1868-1881 | Abraham Owen Smoot | 1815-1895 |
| 1882-1889 | Wilson Howard Dusenberry | 1841-1925 |
| 1890-1891 | John Edge Booth | 1847-1920 |
| 1892-1893 | Warren Newton Dusenberry | 1836-1915 |
| 1894-1897 | Lafayette Holbrook | 1850-1941 |
| 1898-1899 | Samuel Stephen Jones | 1837-1923 |
| 1900-1903 | Thomas Nicholls Taylor | 1868-1950 |
| 1904-1905 | William Martin Roylance | 1865-1925 |
| 1906-1907 | Joseph Hyrum Frisby | 1850-1915 |
| 1908-1909 | Charles Franklin Decker | 1863-1922 |
| 1910-1911 | William H Ray | 1864-1936 |
| 1912-1915 | Charles Franklin Decker | 1863-1922 |
| 1916-1917 | James Edward Daniels | 1853-1941 |
| 1918-1921 | Leroy Dixon | 1881-1926 |
| 1922-1927 | Oscar Keilgaard Hansen | 1874-1930 |
| 1928-1929 | Alma Van Wagenen | 1872-1959 |
| 1930-1933 | Jesse N. Ellertson | 1889-1967 |
| 1934-1935 | Abraham Owen Smoot III | 1879-1937 |
| 1936-1941 | Mark Anderson | 1889-1962 |
| 1941-1945 | Maurice Harding | 1901-1994 |
| 1946-1947 | Mark Anderson | 1889-1962 |
| 1948-1949 | George Earl Collard | 1893-1982 |
| 1950-1953 | Charles William Love Jr. | 1884-1965 |
| 1954-1955 | Aura C. Hatch | 1895-1980 |
| 1956-1957 | Harold E. Van Wagenen | 1909-1992 |
| 1958 | George Marion Hinckley | 1909-2000 |
| 1959-1961 | Lloyd L. Cullimore | 1895-1986 |
| 1961 | Ariel Smith Ballif Sr. | 1901-1995 |
| 1962-1973 | Verl Grant Dixon | 1908-2001 |
| 1974-1977 | Russell D. Grange | 1921-1991 |
| 1978-1986 | James Eldon Ferguson | |
| 1987-1993 | Joseph A. Jenkins | |
| 1993 | Dennis R. Hall | |
| 1993-1994 | Michael R. Hill (interim mayor appointed) | |
| 1994-1997 | George Q. Stewart | |
| 1998-2010 | Lewis K. Billings | |
| 2010- | John Curtis |
