| Cemetery | Date Established | Location/Address | Date Closed | |
| Attica Center Cemetery | June 13, 1817 | Jillson Road | ||
| Brainard Cemetery | Nov. 4, 1832 | East Main Street | ||
| Dunbar Cemetery | Hall's Corner Road | |||
| Eastman Cemetery | Exchange Street Road | |||
| Forest Hill Cemetery | Sept. 29, 1868 | 40 High Street | ||
| Maxon-Lindsey Cemetery | Creek Road | |||
| Prison Cemetery | Dunbar Road | |||
| Saint Vincent Cemetery | 235 Exchange Street | |||
| Schaub Cemetery | Southeast corner of Exchange Street Road and Cascade Road | |||
| 'Old' Exchange Street Cemetery | Exchange Street South of Erie tracks | Oct. 1870 | ||
| Vernal Cemetery | Corner of East Main Street and Vernal Road | |||
| South Attica Cemetery | Exchange Street Road, South of former Zion Evangelical Church, North of Glor Road |
