Beginning in the summer of 1949 fast pitch softball made its debut in Saranac Lake. Games were played on the Petrova Avenue field and fast pitch softball enjoyed a run of twenty six summers providing hard nosed competition between the various teams from the Tri-Lakes, and plenty of enjoyment for spectators. The summer of 1973 was the last season for fast pitch softball and it was also the first season for the new slow pitch league called the Black Fly Softball League. Slow pitch softball became very popular as more players could play the game versus fast pitch softball which was often dominated by an overpowering pitcher and therefore only more skilled players took part in the game. The games could not go on without umpires and for many years the fast pitch league benefited from umpires such as Bob Utting, Donald "Ducky' Martin, and Ralph Sorillo. Ducky Martin also umpired many slow pitch games.
In 1973 Jack Muldowney, owner of a local establishment on Route 86 called Muldowney's Steak House, came up with the idea of forming a slow pitch softball league and Muldowney served as President of the league while long time softball supporter, Donald 'Ducky' Martin served as the Commissioner. On May 22, 1973 the slow pitch games began and seven teams comprised the new league which included the Blue Line Sport Shop, Byno's, The Handlebar, Muldowney's Steak House, Nick & Vern's Restaurant, Sunmount CSEA, and the Swinging Tiger. Games were played in Saranac Lake, Ray Brook, Bloomingdale, Lake Placid, and Tupper Lake. In 1974 there were a total of twelve teams in the league and for many years thereafter up to as many as sixteen teams and over one hundred fifty players were competing each summer for the Black Fly Softball championship.
Black Fly Softball Champions:
1973 - Muldowney's Steak House
1974 - Alpine Hotel
1975 - Alpine Hotel
1976 - Mark's Bar
1977 - Duffy's Cedar Post
1978 - Duffy's Cedar Post
1979 - Mark's Bar
1980 - Club 86
1981 - Belvedere
1982 - Back Door
1983- Rondack Room
1984 - Rondack Room
1985 - Belvedere
1986 - Rondack Room
1987 - Belvedere
1988 - Back Door
1989 - Back Door
1990 - Belvedere
1991 - Belvedere
1992 - Belvedere
1993 - Snuffy's Pub II
1994 - Snuffy's
1995 - The Pub
1996 - Mud Puddles
1997 - The Pub
1998 - The Pub
1999 - Roomers
2000 - Vets Club
2001 - Snuffy's Pub
2002 - Rondack Room
2003 - Pub and Brewery
2004 - Rondack Room
2005 - Wiseguy's
2006 - Wiseguy's
2007 - Wiseguy's
2008 - Captain Cook's
2009 - No League existed this year
2010 - Captain Cook's
2011 - Grizzle T's
2012 - Captain Cook's
2013 - Captain Cook's
2014 - The Shamrock
2015 - Wiseguy's
2016 - Rusty Nail
2017 - Rusty Nail
2018 - Bitters and Bones
2019 - Tail o' the Pup